Reid Uses Procedural Maneuver to Block Vote on Obama’s Jobs Bill
October 4, 2011
Senate Republicans sought to answer President Obama’s demands for a vote on his jobs plan this afternoon, but were thwarted by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV), who used a parliamentary maneuver meant to block amendments on the Senate floor. Reid then proceeded to accuse Republicans of “obstruction” and engaging in a “political stunt.” [Emphasis added]
Reid used a procedural move known as “filling the tree” – a tactic Reid has perfected during his tenure in the Senate leadership. Filling the tree involves loading legislation with amendments until the limit is reached. Since the majority leader enjoys the right of first recognition – which means he can offer amendments before anyone else – Reid managed to fill the tree before Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) could offer the president’s jobs plan as an amendment to a bill cracking down on Chinese currency manipulation.
McConnell said he would vote against the measure, but that the president is “entitled to a vote on his jobs bill.” With the president suggesting that Republicans were preventing consideration of the legislation, McConnell said, “I wanted to disabuse him of the notion that somehow we’re unwilling to vote on his proposal.”
Reid also confirmed during his floor debate with McConnell that Democrats would not present a unified front on the legislation – let alone capture the seven Republican votes needed for a filibuster-proof supermajority. “A majority of Democrats will support the president’s jobs bill,” Reid said, tacitly acknowledging that at least some would not.
Far from having notable support among the president’s party, Obama’s jobs bill has garnered no cosponsors in either the House or the Senate. Nonetheless, the president has on at least 12 occasions called on Congress to immediately pass the legislation – though Reid insisted that “’right away’ is a relative term” – and in some cases said that Republicans were blocking its consideration.
Obama’s 2012 campaign manager sent an email around the time Reid blocked consideration of the president’s plan. It had the subject line, “They won’t even vote on it.” That email mentioned House Majority Leader Eric Cantor, but not Reid.
THEN ADD THIS:
Obama Blasts Cantor and the GOP on Jobs Bill, No Mention of Harry Reid
By Don Irvine —
October 5, 2011
President Obama went to Texas yesterday to promote the American Jobs Act and to challenge House Majority Leader Eric Cantor to bring it to a vote in Congress.
Obama told the audience at Eastfield Community College in Mesquite, Texas that the Republicans are against the bill simply because he proposed it and said that if he had proposed the Republican party platform they would be against that as well.
Clearly, on the jobs bill, Cantor has become public enemy number one for the White House as press secretary Jay Carney revealed during an Air Force One press gaggle on the way to Dallas.
MR. CARNEY: Okay. We ready? Before I take your questions, I would like to read to you an excerpt from the President’s speech that he will deliver today in Texas. This is just an excerpt:
“Yesterday, the Republican Majority Leader in Congress, Eric Cantor, said that right now he won’t even let the jobs bill have a vote in the House of Representatives. He won’t even give it a vote. Well, I’d like Mr. Cantor to come down here to Dallas and explain what in this jobs bill he doesn’t believe in. Does he not believe in rebuilding America’s roads and bridges? Does he not believe in tax breaks for small businesses or efforts to help veterans? Mr. Cantor should come down to Dallas, look Kim Russell in the eye, and tell her why she doesn’t deserve to get a paycheck again. Come tell her students why they don’t deserve to have their teacher back.
Come tell Dallas construction workers why they should be sitting home instead of fixing our bridges and our schools. Come tell the small business owners and workers in this community why you’d rather defend tax breaks for millionaires than tax cuts for the middle class.
And if you won’t do that, at least put this jobs bill up for a vote so that the entire country knows exactly where every member of Congress stands.”
So that’s from the President’s remarks today where he will focus on teacher layoffs and what the American Jobs Act does to put up to 280,000 teachers who have been laid off back to work and up to 400,000 total teachers to work.
Q So Cantor said that he didn’t think the entire bill would go up for a vote on the floor, but he did say that he thought individual components would go up for a vote. And the Republicans have put out lists of things in the bill that they do support. So isn’t it disingenuous for the President to keep saying that they haven’t told him what they support when they have?
MR. CARNEY: That’s not what he’s saying here. First of all, what is Mr. Cantor afraid of? Why not put it up for a vote and show where he stands and where other members of Congress stand? If he doesn’t support — as apparently he does not — if he does not support putting teachers back to work, demonstrate that through your — through his vote. If he doesn’t support putting construction workers back to work, show the American people that fact.
As I have said repeatedly — and the President himself has said — if Congress, having voted on the entire American Jobs Act, then sends him portions of it or sections of it piece by piece, he will sign those if they are paid for in a way that’s responsible and balanced, and then ask where the rest is.
So we’re not — the criticism that this is all or nothing is disingenuous. It’s a red herring. It’s false. Every section of this American Jobs Act is worthy and has this President’s full support. All of it is worthy. And the point the President is making is simply that if Congressman Cantor or others in Congress, Republicans, don’t believe that we should be doing something now to put teachers back to work, that we should be doing something now to put construction workers back to work, that we should be doing something now to incentivize small businesses to hire veterans — say so. Vote — vote accordingly. But don’t hide behind letters you send to the President. Just tell us where you are. Tell us where you stand on those issues.
And if there are things that they are supportive of that are in the jobs act, well, good, let’s get those done. But first of all, the Senate and the House should vote on the entire bill and explain why, if they oppose it, why they oppose it.
Obama was seemingly trying to channel the populism of Bill Clinton when he told the crowd that “We’ve had folks in Congress who have said they shouldn’t pass this bill because it would give me a win…Give me a win? Give me a break!”
But lost in his rhetoric about Cantor and the GOP’s refusal to vote on the entire bill was the Democratic controlled Senate and their less than enthusiastic response to the American Jobs Act. [Emphasis added]
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid said yesterday that he would revise parts of the bill that some Senate Democrats didn’t like while at the same time blocking Republican efforts to vote on the entire bill.